Boots & Ladders Academy
A customer chose another pro. Ask one optional feedback question, accept the answer without reselling, and improve your next quote with facts.
By Omar Kharbat · · 5 min read
Updated

How do you ask for feedback after a customer chooses another pro?
Accept the decision first. If the person has not asked you to stop contacting them, you can include one optional question about your quote or process in your acknowledgment. Make clear that no answer is required, do not turn the reply into another sales pitch, and do not chase feedback if they stay silent.
This is a learning conversation after an explicit decision—not a way to win back the job. You do not need an explanation to respect a no. Sometimes a simple thank-you is the whole response.
A lost quote is not a verdict on your business
It stings when you spend time understanding a job, write a careful quote, and hear that someone else got it. The temptation is to explain yourself, discount the price, or decide that every customer only wants the cheapest option.
Pause before drawing that conclusion. The customer may share a useful detail, but one answer describes one decision. Silence tells you nothing reliable about price, workmanship, or the provider they selected.
In Grand Opening, Omar Kharbat emphasizes courtesy, listening, and asking questions. The practical adaptation here is to listen without trying to change the person's decision. The optional-feedback scripts below are new examples, not passages from the book.
Ask once, and make the question easy to decline
Use the same ordinary conversation in which they told you their decision. Do not switch to repeated calls or another channel to get an answer. If they asked for no more contact, skip the feedback request.
Fictional example: “Thanks for letting me know. I understand you've chosen another pro, and I won't follow up on this quote. If you're comfortable sharing, what is one thing we could make clearer in our quoting process? No reply needed. Thank you for considering us.”
That is enough. Do not add a survey, several questions, a discount, or a request to see the other company's quote. If you cannot receive criticism without arguing, send only the acknowledgment and review your own process privately.
Listen to the answer without reopening the sale
If they reply, acknowledge what they actually said. You are not asking them to defend their choice, disclose another pro's price, or reconsider a signed agreement.
Fictional reply: “I wasn't sure whether removal of the old materials was included.” A useful response is: “Thank you—that helps me see where the quote was unclear. I'll make the inclusions easier to find in future quotes. All the best with your project.”
Do not answer with “It was on page three,” criticize the selected pro, or offer to beat the price. Correct your future quote's presentation if needed; you do not need to prove the customer read it incorrectly. A thank-you closes the feedback exchange.
Record the reason they gave—not the reason you imagined
Keep a short private note: the quote date, the customer's stated reason if any, the relevant process issue, and whether there is something you can check. Avoid collecting unnecessary personal details or competitor documents.
For the fictional example, record “Customer said removal inclusion was unclear.” Do not record “Lost because competitor was cheaper.” Those are different claims, and only the first was stated.
Review several comparable decisions alongside your actual quote records. A repeated clarity issue may justify testing a better inclusion summary. A single lost job is not evidence that you should cut all prices, change your specialty, or copy a competitor. If no reason was given, record “Reason not provided.”
Close the quote and stop the reminders
Mark the opportunity as declined or closed in your existing system and check that quote-chasing reminders will stop. If you had an informal tentative slot, release it under the understanding you actually made; do not imply that a booked visit or contract can simply be canceled.
Do not publish their private reply as a testimonial or treat it as consent for future marketing. The purpose of the question was to improve your process, not to create a promotional asset.
If there has been no explicit decision, use the unanswered service quote guide in Keep reading below. If the customer is still discussing value or budget, see the related price-objection guide. Those are different stages.
Frequently asked questions
Should I ask why they picked the other contractor? You may invite optional feedback, but a question about your own quoting process is easier to answer without asking them to judge the other business. Do not demand names, prices, or private documents.
What if they do not answer? Leave it there. Do not send a second feedback reminder, infer their reason, or contact them elsewhere.
What if they say price was the reason? Thank them and record that statement accurately. It does not prove that your scope was identical or that your price is wrong for every customer. Review your own costs, scope clarity, and comparable jobs separately.
Can I send an improved offer with my thank-you? Keep the learning request separate from reselling. If the customer independently asks you to revise a proposal later, that is a new conversation—not permission to keep pursuing the closed one.
Where this question comes from
Service pros discuss this tension in Landscape Juice Network's quote follow-up thread, linked under Original source below: replies dated March 19–20, 2017 include asking for feedback when a customer selects another contractor. It is qualitative evidence of a practical question, not proof of search demand or results.
The lesson is small: you can learn from a lost quote without making the customer feel that their decision is still on trial.
Landscape Juice Network; educational adaptation of Omar Kharbat's Grand Opening
Keep reading
Sent the Quote. Heard Nothing? Follow Up Without Chasing.
Follow up on an unanswered service quote with one useful question, honest timing and a clear next step—without pressure, false urgency or endless chasing.
· 5 min read
Customer Says “Too Expensive”? Three Calm Responses for a Service Pro
A practical response to a customer’s price concern: clarify the reason, explain relevant value and agree on a next step without pressure or automatic discounts.
· 5 min read